Apr 12 20:24
1 mo ago
35 viewers *
English term

Commentators

English to French Social Sciences Social Science, Sociology, Ethics, etc. Sociology and politics
In the sociology book that I'm translating (EN > FR), the word "commentator(s)" appears over two dozen times. I find it a bit challenging, because the author uses it to refer to a very broad class of people, who only have in common the fact that they voice comments publicly on current social and political issues - not just in newspapers, but also on Twitter/X, on YouTube, as guests invited on talk shows, etc. - and that they have a broad audience as they do so. My sense is that the author uses it to mean something like "pundits" - but without the "expertise" connotation.

So it would be overly restrictive to translate the term as "journalistes" or "experts"... but "commentateurs" is a bit vague and strange, and I feel it's most commonly associated with the field of sports in French. The closest match I've found so far would be "chroniqueur", but I'm still not very comfortable with it, as it doesn't cover random people with a large following on X for example.

If anyone has any genius idea, which wouldn't require the repeated use of a lengthy periphrase, please let me know!

Discussion

commentators Chroniqueurs
Emmanuella Apr 13:
Commentateur / opinologue / analyste - c'est selon...
https://delibere.fr/lon-reparle-de-francois-fillon-lecture-c...
Isabelle Cluzel Apr 12:
Il me semble que l'emploi en anglais est aussi créé pour l'occasion car c'est vraiment typique de l'époque, le commentaire généralisé sur tout, partout... Personnellement, je mettrais probablement "commentateurs", entre guillemets, ou pas, en expliquant peut-être la première occurrence ?

Proposed translations

+1
11 hrs

opinologues

Terme assez peu employé, mais on trouve parfois "opinologue de plateau", "opinologue du Web", etc.

Peer comment(s):

agree Susana E. Cano Méndez : J'aime!
6 hrs
Something went wrong...
11 days

analystes

The french word "analyste" refers to a person analysing different topics and other people.
Something went wrong...
13 days

Intervenant

Ça décrit ce que vous semblez exprimer
Something went wrong...
Term search
  • All of ProZ.com
  • Term search
  • Jobs
  • Forums
  • Multiple search